Sunday, December 16, 2007

Archive '07 - Bicycle Review (A Midsummer Night's Dream)


This review originally appeared on the Chicagoland Bicycle Federation’s “Roll Film” movie review site (http://www.biketraffic.org/content.php?id=219_0_6_0). Each film was also reviewed by my CBF colleague, Greg Borzo, who focused more on the bike content.


WILLIAM SHAKESPEARE'S A MIDSUMMER NIGHT'S DREAM

3 Wheels

It's difficult (though not impossible) to screw up Shakespeare. When a filmmaker has the greatest words of the English language to fall back on, an engaging viewing experience for the audience is just about guaranteed. The pertinent question for a Shakespeare adaptation is: Does the director's own vision enhance the text or just rely on it?

In the case of Michael Hoffman's 1999 film A Midsummer Night's Dream, a fresh perspective is achieved by updating the play from ancient Greece to late nineteenth century Tuscany. This creates both a sufficiently dreamlike atmosphere and allows for the introduction of bicycles into the action. The bikes here provide two functions. First, as a way to transport Shakespeare's mismatched lovers into the magical forest and, ultimately, as a source of great amusement to the fairies, who can't wait to see what those crazy mortals will come up with next.

The special effects are low-key but effective. My only real complaint is with the somewhat bizarre casting choices made in an attempt to assemble star actors. The most egregious offender is Calista Flockhart who, as the tortured Helena, mugs and preens as if she were still on her goofy TV show. Stanley Tucci, an actor best known for playing uptight corporate types, is an odd choice for the mischievous fairy, Puck.

Kevin Kline was great as Hamlet in the mid-eighties, but when his Dream character, Bottom, is turned into a donkey, both the makeup and performance seem a bit too subtle. The inherent comedy of this donkey-headed character being seduced by the fairy queen, Titania, is lost when this preposterous pairing is meant to be touching. It also doesn't help that Michelle Pfeiffer, though she looks the part, can't really sell the dialogue. Miscast as the film is, this is still one of Shakespeare's most beloved comedies, and it’s far more intelligent and entertaining than most contemporary romantic comedies.

I would be remiss in my critical duties if I did not point you to the significantly better 1968 version of A Midsummer Night's Dream starring Helen Mirren, Judi Dench and Ian Holm. These great actors bring a degree of depth and fun to the proceedings lacking in the 1999 film, though the newer adaptation certainly has the edge in the special effects department. (The fairies in the 1968 film are unevenly covered in green paint.)

Hoffman's A Midsummer Night's Dream never reaches the brilliance of Roman Polanski's Macbeth, Akira Kurosawa's King Lear adaptation, Ran, or Kenneth Branagh's Hamlet, but Shakespeare's tragedies have always been more cinematic than his comedies. Hoffman's Dream is more like Mel Gibson's Hamlet or the mid-nineties version of Twelfth Night—just good enough to wet our appetite to seek out the true greatness of Shakespeare on our own.

Archive '07 - Bicycle Review (Jour de Fete)


This review originally appeared on the Chicagoland Bicycle Federation’s “Roll Film” movie review site (http://www.biketraffic.org/content.php?id=219_0_6_0). Each film was also reviewed by my CBF colleague, Greg Borzo, who focused more on the bike content.


JOUR DE FETE

2 1/2 Wheels

One can look at Jour de fête in one of two ways. In the context of film history, it’s an important moment in the evolution of comedy, as it marked the debut of France’s most acclaimed comedic innovator, Jacques Tati. Judged on its own merits, it’s leisurely, pleasant and droll, eliciting the occasional smile, but never a full belly laugh.

Tati plays the high strung mailman, Francois, who delivers the mail by bike in a small French village that would have been considered old-fashioned even at the time of its 1947 release. Francois has a dream – to deliver the mail like the Americans do – by helicopter. This, and all the other tidbits he’s picked up about life in the far away United States, he’s learned from the movies. His jealousy and begrudging admiration for the American way lead to both slapstick efforts at modernization and anti-American tirades that surprisingly evoke a G-rated Borat.

Here, art and reality intersect because Tati, like his character, also covets American progress, but in the area of filmmaking itself. While France had produced excellent dramas like The Rules of the Game and Children of Paradise, French audiences looking for great comedy had to look towards the States. Tati’s vision was to take the American silent physical comedy and update it for the sound era.

He would achieve critical acclaim in the ’50s when he developed and portrayed the character of Mr. Hulot, the mumbling innocent who would constantly do battle with everyday objects. In each subsequent Hulot film, these battles would become more elaborate as he questioned what kind of progress modernization truly achieved.

Hulot was a direct inspiration to England’s Rowan Atkinson, whose Mr. Bean character brought Tati’s brand of comedy into the ’90s. His other clear disciple is Jerry Lewis, who also favored involved physical gags based on the inability to use everyday objects. Lewis lacked Tati’s subtler qualities, but one thought I had after viewing Jour de fête was that I now understand why the French so admire Jerry Lewis.

Tati also had technical innovations in mind, which were probably pretty neat in 1947 and are considerably less so today. Jour de fête is a black-and-white film that occasionally and strategically introduces color to the frame. The colors tend to be blue and red, which is usually applied to the French flag as well as other areas of the screen Tati wishes to call attention to.

Sound is also handled in an unusual way. The dialogue is muted (and was added after filming without much attention to dubbing) and sound effects are brought forward on the soundtrack. The purpose is to allow the sound to enhance the physical comedy.

What would have enhanced the physical comedy more would have been more of it. While its relaxed look at the quaint village is, well, relaxing, it’s only at the end, when Francois makes it his mission to single-handedly modernize the French postal service (all on his bicycle by the way) that Jour de fête starts to build some energy. Ten minutes later, its over, and its place in film history secured despite not being all that funny.

Archive '07 - Bicycle Review (Messenger)


This review originally appeared on the Chicagoland Bicycle Federation’s “Roll Film” movie review site (http://www.biketraffic.org/content.php?id=219_0_6_0). Each film was also reviewed by my CBF colleague, Greg Borzo, who focused more on the bike content.


MESSENGER

1 Wheel

I imagine the story behind the making of Messenger to be more entertaining and interesting then the film that was actually made. I must imagine it because little information is available about this deservedly obscure little project.

Aspiring writer/director, Norman Loftis, had a seemingly inspired idea – remake the Italian neo-realist classic, The Bicycle Thief, but have it set in a poverty stricken American ghetto to humanize the plight of young African-American families who have been left behind by society to an environment filled with crime and hopelessness. Like then unknown filmmakers, Kevin Smith or Robert Rodriguez, he would scrounge up a few thousand dollars, some cameras and some friends to bring his vision to the screen.

Unfortunately, Mr. Loftis forgot one thing. You have to have some degree of talent to make a good film. None is evident in the final product, which resembles the kind of home movies now typically shown on YouTube. I’ll give him the benefit of the doubt and assume his intentions were noble. Perhaps he didn’t envision a film filled with racist stereotypes of black ghetto culture, but that’s what he’s made.

Messenger’s plot faithfully follows the original Bicycle Thief in most details. One major exception is the protagonist is no longer accompanied by his son, but instead, by his pregnant wife. As in the original, we follow a poor man at the end of his rope. He uses the last of his savings to buy the bike required for his new job as a messenger. When his bike is stolen, he must confront his own morality in deciding how far he’ll go to provide for his family.

That leads to the other major difference between the two films. The hero of The Bicycle Thief is portrayed as a good man whose circumstances test him. Richard Barboza plays Messenger's title character as a thug ready to beat or even shoot anyone he feels threatened by. Its possible to bring such a role to life in a way the audience can relate to, but Barboza can’t act, which makes his character completely unlikable.

Of course Vittorio De Sica, who directed the original also used non-actors. This only works if you have a strong director to bring some authenticity out of the non-actor, something Messenger sorely lacks.To give some credit, however, I must admit there was one line of dialogue that I found clever and enjoyed. After the messenger’s bike is stolen, he gets in a cab and orders the driver to chase the thief. The driver responds, "What, do you think this is the movies?"

Archive '07 - Bicycle Review (The Truman Show)


This review originally appeared on the Chicagoland Bicycle Federation’s “Roll Film” movie review site (http://www.biketraffic.org/content.php?id=219_0_6_0). Each film was also reviewed by my CBF colleague, Greg Borzo, who focused more on the bike content.


THE TRUMAN SHOW

4 Wheels (Spoilers Ahead!)

Bicycles have served many functions in movies. They’ve represented everything from childhood innocence to the drive to win, but The Truman Show may be the only cinematic depiction of the bike as an ominous force that hints all is not what it should be. Bikes make up most of the traffic in Seahaven, but how often do you see nurses riding to the hospital in full uniform?

Jim Carrey is Truman Burbank, a likeable everyman who seems just a little off. In fact, his whole town seems a little off, a bit too idealized, as if it were created for a TV show. As The Truman Show slyly teases at and finally reveals, Truman is the unwitting star of his own 24-hour reality television show that follows his every move and is watched by millions worldwide. Everyone he knows is an actor playing a role and Seahaven is, in fact, a giant set.

This is an enormously creative conceit and, happily, all the talent is in top form to make The Truman Show one of the most thought-provoking and emotionally satisfying films of the nineties. Jim Carrey, who was only known for his over-the-top slapstick at the time, proved himself a real dramatic actor (whose talent would shine even brighter in the phenomenal Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind.) Little bits of Carrey’s shtick do sneak in, but it makes sense because someone raised in such an environment probably would end up a bit odd.

Laura Linney and Ed Harris give stellar supporting performances. Linney is Truman’s (Stepford?) wife who keeps her husband bewildered by launching into impromptu commercials on a regular basis. She is also the aforementioned bicycle-riding nurse and one of the more unsettling elements in Truman’s life. The always reliable Ed Harris plays Christof, the mastermind behind the Truman Show. Harris does not go for the obvious villain notes, but instead, he views himself as Truman’s surrogate father (not that he doesn't love those ratings.)

Veteran Australian director, Peter Weir, at first seems an unconventional choice for such a high concept film, but just as he did in Witness, Weir expertly empathizes with the experience of being a stranger in a foreign community.

It’s interesting to note that The Truman Show was released at the very beginning of the reality television craze and, as a result, holds it in a much more charitable light than if it had been made today. The filmmakers were naïve enough to portray a television audience satisfied with watching a real life unfold naturally and rooting for their hero’s happiness. How sad that the reverse turned out to be the case, and reality TV shows would mostly become cesspools of exploitation, greed and bringing out the worst in people.

Would we be better off in Seahaven? Like our hero, it’s a decision we all must make individually. Fortunately, once in a while, a special film like The Truman Show comes along to help us dig deeper and be entertained at the same time.

Archive '07 - Bicycle Review (The Good German)


This review originally appeared on the Chicagoland Bicycle Federation’s “Roll Film” movie review site (http://www.biketraffic.org/content.php?id=219_0_6_0). Each film was also reviewed by my CBF colleague, Greg Borzo, who focused more on the bike content.


THE GOOD GERMAN

3 Wheels

The Good German may be a gimmick movie, but I have to admit, it's a damn good gimmick. It's filmed in the style of those classic spy thriller/love stories of the 1940s. It's not just the black and white cinematography, but the film stock, limited camera movements, use of sound and acting styles that give the distinct impression that this 2006 film was made in 1945, when the action of the story takes place.

Nowhere is this more powerful than the opening credits. The frame is cropped to eliminate the wide-screen that had not yet been developed in the period setting, while the retro-lettering and music seem to take you back in time. I could not stop grinning throughout the credits, but soon enough, it became apparent that the film itself is rather dark in nature. There are a few areas that The Good German distinctly does not make period, allowing for the inclusion of profanity, sex and violence.

George Clooney plays a reporter covering the Potsdam Conference which, in the wake of Hitler's defeat in World War II, will determine how Germany is to be divided. Berlin is itself divided into American, British and Russian sectors leading to much postwar intrigue between the Americans and Russians. In this, the film is reminiscent of perhaps the best '40s spy thriller, The Third Man with Orson Welles as Harry Lime, one of the all-time great movie villains. Its tone is much closer to that film than Casablanca, which The Good German's publicity is trying to emulate.

Casablanca is paid homage to near the end, but bike fans will also appreciate how similar postwar Berlin appears to the postwar Italy of The Bicycle Thief. Just as in the Italian film, bicycles are seen often as a practical means of transportation in the Europe of that period. Additionally, "The Good German" of the title, portrayed by Cate Blanchett, attends to a number of her covert activities (being purposefully vague here) on her bike.

Blanchett plays an old flame of Clooney's, but as the film opens, is shacking up with Tobey Maguire, whose sleazy role couldn't be further from his Spider-Man persona. As Blanchett's character is viewed with suspicion as a possible Nazi or Nazi sympathizer, the real theme of the film takes shape. With all the atrocities that took place in Nazi Germany, what of the supposed "Good Germans" who collaborated through seemingly unknowing action or silence. This issue's complexity is in stark contrast to the black and white film style.

Steven Soderbergh is an ambitious, but inconsistent director. His highlights include Sex, Lies, and Videotape, Out of Sight, and Traffic, but he can also be dragged down by failed experiments like Solaris and Full Frontal or the mindless commerciality of the Ocean's 11 films. With The Good German, Soderbergh has made a film that is too slow for the effect he seeks, but it really has something to say. Its own inconsistencies are the result of deliberately trying to bring two eras of film into one. They don't exactly fit, but it's fascinating to watch him try.

Archive '06 - Bicycle Review (Malena)


This review originally appeared on the Chicagoland Bicycle Federation’s “Roll Film” movie review site (http://www.biketraffic.org/content.php?id=219_0_6_0). Each film was also reviewed by my CBF colleague, Greg Borzo, who focused more on the bike content.


MALENA

1 1/2 Wheels

Malèna, an Italian film released in 2000, manages to accomplish a couple unusual feats. First, it's both juvenile and pretentious. More surprisingly, it's somehow managed to make the subject of sex utterly boring.

It begins as a typical coming-of-age tale in which 12-year-old Renato falls in love with the beautiful, but unattainable Malèna, played by model-turned-actress Monica Bellucci. Had this been an American film, it would be dismissed as a childish sex romp in the vein of Porky's or one of the American Pie sequels. I doubt their European counterparts are any better, but they certainly try to put more sophisticated gloss on their otherwise prurient subject matter.

So here we have an attempted sex comedy with serious overtones set in World War II Sicily, and Malèna is called upon to be both sex object and martyr. I'm sure we're supposed to read some kind of symbolism between the war and Malèna's suffering, but it would take a better film to hit that point home.

You see, in Malèna's village, nobody seems to have ever seen a beautiful woman before. When her husband goes missing in the war, every male immediately begins to lust after her and devise plans to get her into bed. Every woman burns with intense jealousy and assumes Malèna to be a prostitute. Only our young narrator, whose point of view we, as an audience, are expected to share, truly loves her. He proves this love by spying on her in various states of undress.

None of this is inherently inappropriate subject matter, but there are no full-blooded human beings portrayed on screen. We know exactly one thing about every character. For Malèna, it's loyalty to her husband. For Renato, it's his obsession with Malèna. For everyone else, it's either lust or hate for Malèna. So we really can't care about this kid's coming of age, since we don't know much about him. Malèna is reduced to her appearance and nothing else.

Unfortunately, this leads to a mean streak of misogyny in the film, demonstrated by its questionable use of nudity. Nudity, properly used, can be either an erotic force or a window into the souls of more fully developed characters. (See Body Heat for the former or Nashville for the latter.) While most of the exposure consists of quick, shadowy glimpses, the one scene of sustained and clear nudity is also one of violence and humiliation. Again, if Malèna were a three dimensional character, such a moment might have been powerful and horrifying. As it is, it's just exploitation.

Malèna is a bicycle movie in that Renato is given a bike at the beginning of the film and rides throughout. There's some dialogue to the effect that receiving his bicycle is a sign of his maturity. If so, it's the only sign of maturity to be found in this dull film.

Archive '06 - Bicycle Review (Wired To Win)


This review originally appeared on the Chicagoland Bicycle Federation’s “Roll Film” movie review site (http://www.biketraffic.org/content.php?id=219_0_6_0). Each film was also reviewed by my CBF colleague, Greg Borzo, who focused more on the bike content.


WIRED TO WIN

3 Wheels (if in Omnimax, 2 otherwise)

Any movie worth seeing is worth seeing in a theater, on a big screen and with an audience. Every time we watch a movie on cable or DVD, we’re watching a compromised version. Of course, in the real world, it’s impractical to limit our film-going to theaters, and it’s better to watch compromised versions of great films than miss them altogether. A film shot for an OMNIMAX theater, however, is a different story. Here the scope and scale of the screen is so vital to the experience that to view it outside that context means to literally be viewing a different film.

All this is a preface to my main point, which is that Wired to Win: Surviving the Tour de France is worth seeing, but only in its OMNIMAX format. As a film, it’s just so-so, but seen in its original format, there are scenes that take your breath away. A reminder - OMNIMAX is not simply a giant screen, as in IMAX. These movies can only be shown in specialized theaters, like the screenings we attended at Chicago’s Museum of Science and Industry. The images are projected onto a domed interior so that the film takes up your entire field of vision.

Wired to Win is a short documentary with a split personality. It’s mostly Tour de France 101, describing the logistics of the 2003 race while showcasing featured riders. This is now the third Tour de France film we’ve reviewed (La Course en Tête and Hell on Wheels being the others), yet it’s the first not to assume a pre-existing detailed knowledge of the race on the part of the viewer.

When not on the road with Lance and friends, Wired to Win doubles as a very basic educational film. Computer graphics take the viewer through simulations of the human brain and how its electrical impulses affect the body and lead to our mental and physical functioning. Much time is devoted to the question of what makes us strive towards our goals despite great obstacles, few of which are more intense than those faced by Tour athletes.

Because Wired to Win only uses the Tour de France as a backdrop, the race itself provides only sporadic drama. Most notable is Lance Armstrong’s remarkable comeback after taking a nasty spill. French cyclist, Jimmy Caspar, suffers an injury early in the race, providing the filmmakers with an ideal opportunity to connect his recovery and return to the race with the science behind his motivation.

Were the film shown in a standard theater setting, all this would be informative, but not fascinating. What’s memorable is the visual panorama that OMNIMAX provides. A real "you are there" vibe prevails as the scenic mountains and countryside of France loom in front of and above your eyes. As the riders make sharp turns along the roads, the theater itself seems to tilt. What would otherwise seem to be cheesy graphics of brain synapses instead become a psychedelic 3D ride.

OMNIMAX is well suited to showcasing spectacles like Wired to Win. What would really be something is if some truly visionary filmmakers found a way to use the format to service the narrative as well as the visuals.